| Pastor | Years of Service |
| Fr. William Poole | 1865 – 1915 |
| Fr. Thomas Heafy | 1915 – 1930 |
| Fr. Thomas McLaughlin | 1930 – 1941 |
| Fr. John Sheridan | 1941 – 1950 |
| Msgr. Matthew Deahy | 1950 – 1961 |
| Msgr. Andrew Quinn | 1961 – 1983 |
| Fr. Joseph Collins | 1983 – 1988 |
| Fr. James Burke | 1988 – 2003 |
| (Fr. Louis Jerome served as Administrator from | 2001 – 2003) |
| Fr. Louis Jerome | 2003 – 2015 |
| Fr. Eric Rapaglia | 2015 – 2022 |
| Fr. Rizalino Garcia | 2022 – |